1984 American League Fernando Valenzuela Washington Past Timers W L ERA 23 10 2.62	1984 National League Storm Davis Lauderdale Breakers W L ERA 23 1 2.06
1983 American League Mario Soto Fort Worth Panthers W L ERA 27 4 3.10	1983 National League Larry Mcwilliams Hollywood Vampires W L ERA 19 5 2.25
1982 American League Mario Soto Fort Worth Panthers W L ERA 22 5 2.51	1982 National League Dan Petry Germantown Grays W L ERA 18 11 2.08
1981 American League Jerry Reuss Baton Rouge Ragin' Cajuns W L ERA 15 3 1.86	1981 National League Larry Gura Jacksonville Red Caps W L ERA 14 7 2.34
1980 American League Steve Carlton Quebec City Le Blue W L ERA 29 5 1.93	1980 National League Larry Gura Jacksonville Red Caps W L ERA 20 9 2.18
1979 American League Mike Caldwell Detroit Stars W L ERA 33 5 2.64	1979 National League Mike Flanagan Gold River Miners W L ERA 23 7 2.83
1978 American League Mike Caldwell Detroit Stars W L ERA 32 3 1.99	1978 National League Rick Waits Germantown Grays W L ERA 24 4 2.65
1977 American League Ron Guidry Detroit Stars W L ERA 23 3 1.88	1977 National League Nolan Ryan Long Beach Titans W L ERA 22 14 3.07
1976 American League Jim Palmer Old Mill Legends W L ERA 29 10 1.69	1976 National League Randy Jones Thendera Thugs W L ERA 26 5 1.57
1975 American League Jim Palmer Old Mill Legends W L ERA 30 9 1.94	1975 National League Andy Messersmith Hollywood Vampires W L ERA 29 5 1.58
1974 American League Phil Niekro Old Mill Legends W L ERA 36 5 2.29	1974 National League Jim Kaat Long Beach Titans W L ERA 21 5 2.05
1973 American League Don Sutton Old Mill Legends W L ERA 29 5 2.12	1973 National League Andy Messersmith Hollywood Vampires W L ERA 20 8 2.47
1972 American League Catfish Hunter Chicago Demolition W L ERA 22 5 1.84	1972 National League Gaylord Perry Lauderdale Breakers W L ERA 22 9 1.78
1971 American League Vida Blue Chicago Demolition W L ERA 22 13 2.29	1971 National League Mike Cuellar Thendera Thugs W L ERA 24 9 2.39
1970 American League Bob Gibson Punxsutawney Philibusters W L ERA 33 7 2.35	1970 National League Wayne Simpson Rushcreek Lakers W L ERA 20 6 1.96