2009 American League C.c. Sabathia Chicago Mobsters W L ERA 19 7 2.74	2009 National League Derek Lowe Kentucky Head Hunters W L ERA 18 5 2.72
2008 American League Brandon Webb Severn Express W L ERA 27 5 2.38	2008 National League Chien-ming Wang Tempe Tempers W L ERA 22 5 1.34
2007 American League Roy Halladay Yonge Street Stalkers W L ERA 19 5 1.78	2007 National League Jason Schmidt Los Angeles Riots W L ERA 23 5 2.61
2006 American League Andy Pettitte Virginia Sluggers W L ERA 23 5 1.56	2006 National League Roger Clemens Tempe Tempers W L ERA 30 0 1.24
2005 American League Johan Santana Detroit Crime W L ERA 23 9 2.15	2005 National League Randy Johnson New River Road Runners W L ERA 24 7 1.91
2004 American League Hideo Nomo Hollywood Werewolves W L ERA 21 5 2.80	2004 National League Jason Schmidt Los Angeles Riots W L ERA 29 2 1.58
2003 American League Jamie Moyer Buffalo Braves W L ERA 16 7 2.15	2003 National League Pedroj. Martinez Tempe Tempers W L ERA 20 5 1.97
2002 American League Greg Maddux Chicago Mobsters W L ERA 23 3 1.88	2002 National League Curt Schilling New River Road Runners W L ERA 21 7 2.41
2001 American League Pedroj. Martinez Severn Express W L ERA 29 0 1.51	2001 National League Randy Johnson Tempe Tempers W L ERA 31 1 2.40
2000 American League Pedroj. Martinez Severn Express W L ERA 20 7 2.29	2000 National League Kevin Brown Los Angeles Riots W L ERA 23 8 2.12
1999 American League Pedroj. Martinez East Lansing Kegs W L ERA 26 1 2.36	1999 National League Greg Maddux Tempe Tempers W L ERA 26 2 2.05
1998 American League Pedroj. Martinez Ohio Valley Buckeyes W L ERA 20 4 1.75	1998 National League Roger Clemens Tempe Tempers W L ERA 28 4 2.16
1997 American League Pat Hentgen Emporium Red Raiders W L ERA 29 4 2.87	1997 National League Kevin Brown Tempe Tempers W L ERA 20 6 1.89